25 Cayuga WalkFire Island, NY 11770 Phone: +1 631-583-8000Fax: +1 631-597-6595 Hotel E-mailHotel Website Commission Rooms Rates - 38 $1,047-$2,073 (USD) Hoteliers! Is your information accurate? Update Here Fire Island Beach House Location & Neighborhood On Fire Island, accessible by ferry from Bayshore Long Island - 10 MI from Long Is MacArthur airport.Hotel Location: Tourist