35 Shore Rd PO Box 278Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 Phone: +1 631-749-2001Fax: +1 631-749-1843 Hotel E-mailHotel Website Commission Rooms Rates - 20 - Hoteliers! Is your information accurate? Update Here Sunset Beach Location & Neighborhood 50 MI from Long Is MacArthur airport. New York CityHotel Location: Beach, Lake, Tourist